The costs associated with settling an estate can differ widely throughout Canada since laws regarding probate, court costs, Estate Administration Tax, and succession law depend largely on the provincial or territorial jurisdiction. For instance, in Ontario, there is no Estate Administration Tax levied on the first $50,000 of the estate, but everything above it is charged at $15 for every $1,000 or portion thereof. The Estate Administration Tax leviable on an Ontario estate with a value of $1 million would thus amount to around $14,250 without including any lawyer, accountant, valuator, and executor costs.
A different probate system is used in British Columbia, whereas Alberta has fixed court filing costs for estates instead of a percentage-based cost of the total value of the estate.
Probate is just one component of estate planning. On the death of an individual, the Canada Revenue Agency considers many capital properties as having been disposed of right before death. In the process, they might lead to taxable capital gains even though provisions for rollover may apply when transferring certain assets to a spouse.
Proper estate planning should take into account probate implications, taxation, liquidity, designation of beneficiaries, family situations, property ownership, and the time taken to dispose of the property. The aim should not necessarily be to save on all probate fees. It should be to pass the property without any legal disputes, taxation, or difficulties.
How Probate Works In Canada
The probate process is a legal procedure carried out by the courts to authenticate the validity of the will and authorize the executor or the personal representative.
Financial institutions, land registries, and other financial services may need to receive the probate process to allow them to transfer, sell or distribute any asset belonging to the estate.
According to the Government of British Columbia, probate is a legal process through which a court validates whether a will is authentic, the last will of the deceased and one that has not been forged or influenced unduly. Such financial institutions may require a probate process before they accept the authority of the executor.
Generally, the process entails looking for the original will, naming the executor, making an asset and liability statement, making a court application where necessary, filing tax documents, settling any outstanding liability, and distributing the remaining assets to beneficiaries.
The requirement for probate is not always applicable to all estates. It is determined by the kind of assets owned, their value, the way they are held, the institution that holds those assets, the province, as well as the existence of valid beneficiaries’ designation. While a small bank account can at times pass through probate, real estate which is owned in the sole name of the deceased person cannot pass through probate.
Not having a probate is not necessarily always the right course of action. In some instances, the probate grant serves to protect the institution from possible risks associated with dealing with the executor.
Probate And Estate Administration Tax Across Canada
There is some misconception regarding the term probate fee and Estate Administration Tax being used interchangeably in all Canadian provinces. Actually, each province has its own specific policy.
In Ontario, it is called Estate Administration Tax. No tax will be levied for the initial amount up to $50,000 for estate value in applications of certificates filed on and after January 1, 2020. However, the tax imposed on the excess amount of $50,000 is $15 per $1,000 of the total estate value.
In British Columbia, there will be no probate fee charged when the estate is valued below $25,000. Otherwise, in cases exceeding this amount, graduated percentages under the Probate Fees Act will apply.
In Alberta, there is usually no percentage-based probate fee but a court filing fee applies instead. A fee of $300 applies for filing a document for which a court file on the estate needs to be opened.
Cost savings could be quite large. If a person owns property in multiple provinces, there might be some other requirements imposed by law and administration. Prior to implementing any probate avoidance measures, one should determine under what province’s laws that property falls and whether there will be any tax implications, ownership or family-law implications.
Which Assets Usually Form Part Of The Estate?
Property that is individually owned by the decedent and does not have a proper means of direct transfer will be included in the estate. Examples of such property are individually-owned real property, investment accounts which are not registered, personal bank accounts, vehicles, business interests, personal property of value, and insurance benefits payable to the estate.
Probate qualification for an asset is a different issue than its tax liability. The asset may not go through the estate process, yet it may trigger taxes. Likewise, the asset may enter the estate without triggering any large income tax.
It is crucial to remember this difference in thinking about ways to shield your asset from probate. Transferring the asset out of the estate process may lower the court fees; however, it may alter the ownership, place the property at risk of other people’s creditors, change tax liability, etc.
Probate planning should therefore begin with a complete asset inventory. The inventory should record ownership, account type, approximate value, beneficiary designation, tax cost, debt attached to the asset, and the province where it is located.
Use A Valid And Updated Will
A will does not guarantee avoidance of probate. It does, however, provide detailed instructions to the executor, names the intended beneficiaries, and minimizes uncertainty during estate administration.
A well-written will includes provisions regarding the appointment of an executor, nomination of guardians of the minor children, creation of trusts, making of tax elections, instruction of personal property, and dealing with the case of the death of the beneficiary. Powers which the will should grant are dependent on the jurisdiction and the nature of the estate.
A poorly written will will result in increased costs regardless of low probate fees because of issues such as the death of the named executor, unclear beneficiaries, disposition of the assets, second marriage not considered in the will, and incompatibility between the will and the beneficiary designation of the accounts.
The need for review of the will is necessary for retirement and estate planning in situations such as marriage, separation, divorce, birth of a child, death of a beneficiary, buying a business, relocation to another jurisdiction, and significant changes in net worth.
Life Insurance Beneficiary Planning
A Life Insurance beneficiary designation can be an effective means of distributing funds independent of the estate. If there is a valid beneficiary and he/she survives the insured party, then the insurer is free to pay the death benefits to the named beneficiary rather than the estate itself.
The above arrangement will help deal with the issue of whether beneficiaries can bypass probate. There are situations when, as part of the death benefit payment process, some proceeds of insurance and registered plans may go to the beneficiaries without first being probated by the entire estate. Nevertheless, there will be specific circumstances in which this result will depend on the specific policy and designation as well as provincial laws.
In most cases, naming the estate as the beneficiary of the plan will include the proceeds within the estate. As a result, they will be available for distribution after tax and other liabilities.
A contingent beneficiary needs to be named in the event that the primary beneficiary dies before the insured person. This designation needs to be checked in the event that someone gets divorced or remarried. The will and insurance policy should not be viewed separately since it may result in litigation.
Life Insurance For Estate Planning
Life Insurance for estate planning is often used to create liquidity rather than merely to replace income. An estate may contain substantial property but very little cash. A family cottage, rental property, farm, private corporation, or investment portfolio may create taxes and settlement costs even when beneficiaries do not want the assets sold.
A Life Insurance death benefit can provide money for:
- Final income tax
- Estate administration expenses
- Legal and accounting costs
- Outstanding debts
- Equalization among beneficiaries
- Charitable gifts
- Business succession obligations
- Maintenance of family property
The legal representative of a deceased individual is obligated to file final tax returns and settle any outstanding balances before dividing up the assets of the estate. The CRA also provides the service of providing clearance certificates as proof of payment or securing certain tax obligations.
Life Insurance estate planning prevents the beneficiaries from having to liquidate the asset to obtain funds within a short period of time. However, Life Insurance estate planning does not eliminate the necessity of having some form of legal and tax planning.
Whole Life Insurance Estate Planning
Whole Life Insurance estate planning can be appropriate for those individuals who require insurance that will provide protection throughout their lifetime as opposed to being required only for a specified period of time.
It is useful to consider permanent insurance if there is an expectation that the need for protection will not end when the individual retires. This could be in connection with financing tax on a family cottage, ensuring that there is an inheritance, taking care of a dependent child, making equalization of estate and/or funding business continuation.
Many whole life plans carry a cash value feature, and some plans offer dividends, even though they are not guaranteed. Premium payments tend to be higher than premiums for similar term insurance plans because of the permanent nature of the plan.
The policy itself needs to revolve around a specific objective of the estate. Having too much coverage for what the family can afford to maintain might lead to lapsed policies, whereas having insufficient coverage might fail to generate enough liquidity. These and other product-related considerations must be assessed by licensed and competent individuals.
Review Beneficiaries On Registered Accounts
The registered retirement and savings plans may allow for the nomination of beneficiaries or successor holders, depending on the plan and provincial laws.
The nomination of a beneficiary might help facilitate the transmission of some property but should not be overlooked due to taxation issues. Avoidance of probate does not mean avoidance of taxes.
Thus, for instance, CRA stipulates that the fair market value of the TFSA of the decedent may be paid out free of tax either to the estate or to the designated individual, but the appreciation after the death of the owner might be taxable in specific conditions.
RRSP and RRIF need special tax considerations since the value of such plans is usually included in the total income of the deceased unless some tax-saving measure is used. The estate plan should specify which individual gets the funds and who pays taxes.
It is recommended to reconsider all the nominations along with the will as naming one beneficiary of a registered fund and equal division of the remainder of the property among children could lead to an inequality.
Consider Joint Ownership Carefully
Joint ownership is often presented as an easy method for lowering the cost of probate. If there is a true joint tenancy with the right of survivorship, the survivor can inherit the property outright from the deceased owner.
While this may be applicable to some couples, problems can arise when an adult child is made an owner of the asset or account. The transaction could be construed as a gift, agency relationship, resulting trust, or beneficial interest depending on the circumstances and provincial law.
Potential risks include:
- Exposure to the joint owner’s creditors
- Family-law claims involving the joint owner
- Loss of control over the asset
- Capital-gains consequences
- Difficulty selling or refinancing property
- Conflict among children
- Questions about whether the surviving owner was meant to keep the asset
Saving a probate fee is rarely worthwhile if the arrangement creates a larger tax bill or family dispute. Legal advice should be obtained before transferring ownership of a home, cottage, investment account, or business interest.
Use Trusts Only When They Serve A Clear Purpose
Trusts have a role to play in wealth preservation planning, but they are not a probate solution applicable to everyone. Property can remain separate from an individual’s estate and exist independently through a trust after the person dies.
Alter ego trusts and joint partner trusts could be available to eligible Canadians who are 65 years or older. Trusts could be used in cases where there are minors, people with disability, blended families, business succession planning, or long-term management of inherited wealth.
The cost associated with a trust includes initial setup costs, annual tax filings, accounting costs, legal obligations, and complicated rules about income tax on trust. The trust could be subjected to taxes at a rate that differs from an individual.
The probate savings need to be weighed against the entire cost of creating and maintaining the trust throughout the lifetime. A trust will make more sense when it addresses more than one issue rather than being created purely to save a small court fee.
Plan For Private Corporations And Business Interests
The business owner might face more issues of probate and liquidity. The shares of a private corporation could be included in the estate and could impact the amount of probate costs and income taxes.
A shareholder agreement will determine how the passing away of an owner should be handled. It will specify a way of evaluating the shares, purchasing them by other shareholders or the use of Life Insurance.
Corporation-owned Life Insurance could generate some funds to buy back shares, pay off the debts and keep everything functioning properly. Depending on the tax laws and the type of insurance, some portion of the death benefits paid out by Life Insurance to a private corporation could be included in the capital dividend account of the company.
There should be coordination between the will, shareholder agreement, insurance policy and other documentation regarding business succession. The conflicting documents could lead to delays and diminish the value passed on to heirs.
Probate Planning For Retirees
Probate planning for retirees should focus on control, income security, incapacity, tax, and the intended inheritance. Reducing probate costs should not weaken the retiree’s ability to fund daily living, care expenses, or emergencies.
A retiree may have a home, registered accounts, a pension, non-registered investments, insurance policies, and family property. Each asset may pass differently at death.
Retirees should review:
- Whether beneficiary designations remain current
- Whether the executor can locate important documents
- Whether sufficient cash will be available for tax and expenses
- Whether jointly owned assets reflect the true intention
- Whether a dependent beneficiary requires a trust
- Whether the will complies with current provincial law
- Whether the estate can be divided fairly without selling important property
An enduring or continuing power of attorney should also be part of the plan. Probate deals with authority after death, while a power of attorney addresses financial decision-making during incapacity.
How Beneficiaries Can Avoid Probate Delays
Beneficiaries do not always have control over the necessity of probate after the death, however, good preparations will help minimize unnecessary delays.
An estate plan should consist of a well-organized list of financial accounts, insurance, real estate, debt, digital assets, professional contacts, and actual documents. Executors must know where the original will can be found and be able to contact the estate attorney and accountants.
Beneficiaries’ designation needs to contain full legal names and be changed in case the situation changes. Contingent beneficiaries may ensure that the money will not be left to the estate if the designated beneficiary is deceased.
It is important not to distribute assets before necessary because, according to the CRA, the representative is responsible for paying all taxes before distributing the estate assets. Clearance certificates can help avoid the responsibility of the executor for the payments made under the certificate.
Beneficiaries can also help by providing requested identification and tax information promptly. Disputes, missing documents, unlocated beneficiaries, and incomplete asset records can cause longer delays than the probate application itself.
What Happens If There Is No Estate Plan?
The absence of a proper will makes it necessary to look into intestacy law in the province to see who is entitled to inherit from the estate, which is unlikely to be in accordance with the wishes of the deceased.
An executor might be required to be appointed by the court and the person appointed as the executor is not necessarily going to be the one whom the deceased wanted.
Beneficiary planning ensures that there are no unnecessary assets that are transferred into the estate. Liquidity planning ensures that nothing will need to be sold in order to settle any debts and pay any taxes on the estate. Guardianship planning ensures that the court does not decide on guardianship of any minors.
There are no government policies that say that all money goes to the government. Statutory laws take effect when there is no proper estate planning and the problem is that they differ greatly in Canada and are extremely inappropriate in some cases.
Common Mistakes When Reducing Probate Costs
Reducing probate costs can be useful, but aggressive planning may create larger problems.
- Focusing Only On Probate Fees: Probate may represent a relatively small cost compared with capital-gains tax, legal disputes, or the loss of control over an asset.
- Adding Children As Joint Owners Without Advice: Joint ownership may expose the asset to creditors, relationship breakdown, and disagreement over beneficial ownership.
- Naming The Estate As Beneficiary Without A Reason: This may bring proceeds into the estate when a direct beneficiary designation would have achieved the intended result.
- Failing To Coordinate Documents: A will, insurance policy, registered account, trust, and shareholder agreement should operate as one estate plan.
- Using Outdated Beneficiary Designations: A designation made many years ago may no longer reflect family relationships or tax objectives.
- Giving Away Too Much Property During Life: Probate may be reduced, but the person may lose access to assets needed for retirement or long-term care.
- Assuming Probate Avoidance Means Tax Avoidance: Assets outside the estate may still produce income tax when the owner dies.
When Professional Advice Is Important
Where the estate comprises stocks in private companies, numerous properties, overseas investments, a step-family situation, a mentally or physically challenged heir, a desire for charities, capital gains, or a potential familial disagreement, the importance of legal, taxation, and insurance advice is especially high.
Where joint ownership, an alter ego trust, corporate-owned Life Insurance, the preparation of more than one will where legally permissible, or a substantial intergenerational inheritance is being contemplated, professional advice may prove to be useful.
For a deceased individual, the last return discloses income and the appreciation in the fair market value of property to the date of death. As taxation and probate computations have different goals, both should be simulated prior to any change in ownership or beneficiaries.
A lawyer may give advice about wills, trusts, ownership, and provincial succession laws. An accountant will be able to estimate the tax implications. An insurance expert can evaluate liquidity requirements of the estate and adequate insurance.
Final Thoughts
Decreasing probate fees starts with knowledge about probate process, the types of property that would likely become part of the estate, and the way provincial fees operate. Having a will, being up to date with the beneficiary designations, good asset structure, sufficient liquidity, and cooperation of professionals can make estate administration more streamlined.
Life Insurance estate planning can help to accelerate the transfer of money to beneficiaries or to provide an estate with some cash to pay taxes and settle accounts. Permanent Life Insurance estate planning can work when there is a continuous need, but sometimes trusts, registered account designations, and joint ownership can do well in some instances.
There is no one-size-fits-all solution. The best estate plans are those that achieve probate savings and tax efficiency, retirement planning, family fairness, creditor protection, and control.
A carefully structured plan can preserve more wealth, reduce unnecessary delays, and give executors clearer instructions. The objective is not simply to pay the lowest possible probate fee. It is to transfer assets in a way that protects the owner during life and supports beneficiaries after death.
Learn More: Life Insurance Riders: Types, Benefits & Working